Måske var jeg lidt for fuld igår - kan dog godt stå inde for det - ingen dumheder såvidt jeg kan se. Kan desuden fortælle dig, Arne, at jeg har fået talt lidt med en fra hare krishna bevægelsen om "sjælens rejse". Det med sjælens første inkarnation. Han fortalte mig desuden, at der var beviser for, at mennesket var her for 200-300 millioner år siden. Mener det var det han sagde. Jeg spurgte selvfølgelig efter beviserne, for jeg har kun hørt om 5-10 millioner år. Men han sagde, at vi blev misinformeret og henviste til bogen - forbudt arkæologi.
Nu ved jeg ikke om I orker at læse tråden igennem, men der er nogle interessante links, som nok er værd at læse:
http://www.truthbeknown.com/biblemyth.htm https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Bible_in_History:_How_Writers_Create_a_Past
Men tilbage til debatten, for jeg stillede dette spørgsmål i tråden:
Some like the hare krishna movement say we are eternal souls who always has existed together with Krishna in the spiritual world, but then (at some point in time) we turned away from Krishna, and because of that we were sent (or was falling) into the material world. I think we could learn mush by investigating this idea. Can we say that it is not true?
Og en fra Jehovas Vidner svarede så dette:
We most certainly can. Humans do not have an immortal soul that is a Satanic lie, don't believe it.
Hertil svarede jeg så:
You do not seem to get the question...what do you think the hare krishna movement would or could say to you? It is a Satanic lie that we do not have a soul? So who is right? You? Them? Because? If this is true then this cannot be true...that is right. But is it true? Let us think about the idea. They may be wrong about some things but that does not mean they are wrong about everything. So lets keep an open mind and investigate the idea. Can we say that it is not true?
Han svarede så tilbage, og gentog, at det var en løgn (tager kun dette med fra svaret):
https://debatingchristianity.com/forum/viewtopic.p...sc&start=60I have already investigated the idea, my conclusion is it's a lie. I am now ready to share my findings with others to help them if they would like help.
Og nu skal jeg så svare tilbage. Kan desuden fortælle, at hvis man ønsker at blive klogere på videnskab og sådan noget, så er det lige stedet. Det er nogle skarpe hjerner som debattere derinde.
Håber på en god debat.
Kærlig hilsen
ABC
Svar
Citer
